11 Unique Things to Do in Key West, Florida
This post contains affiliate links, which help support my blog at no extra cost to you!
Some of the most unique things to do in Key West involve six-toed cats, shipwreck treasure, and a bar so small you could walk right past it. I love the island’s waterfront drinks and pretty sunsets, but the little details are what make exploring here so much fun. You can shop for sandals made right in town, take a boat to dinner, or spend an afternoon learning why people write apology letters to a doll. Yep, a doll!
This list mixes quirky Old Town stops, local food and shopping, and a few bigger experiences worth planning around. Some are famous, some are easier to overlook, and each gives you a reason to spend a little more time in Key West!
Unique Things to Do in Key West
1. Take a Day Trip to Dry Tortugas National Park
An enormous brick fort surrounded by blue water, about 70 miles west of Key West? This is the experience I’d plan the rest of the trip around. Dry Tortugas National Park feels far removed from Duval Street, with Fort Jefferson, beaches, and snorkeling all waiting out on Garden Key.
Getting there takes planning: the Yankee Freedom ferry is a full-day outing, while the seaplane offers half-day and full-day options with incredible aerial views along the way.
For a rough budget, expect $250+ per adult for the ferry and $500+ per adult for a half-day seaplane trip. Check both websites for current pricing before planning your trip.
This is one of the unique things to do in Key West you’ll definitely want to book in advance, especially if you’re taking the ferry! It’s the more affordable option, and spots can fill up quickly. It takes a little more planning and budget than the other experiences on this list, so reserve as soon as you know your dates and leave some flexibility in case weather affects your departure.

2. Meet the Six-Toed Cats at Hemingway’s House
You don’t need to have a Hemingway novel on your nightstand to enjoy the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum. The house and gardens are interesting on their own, but the resident polydactyl cats give this historic home a personality all its own.
Several have extra toes, and some are descendants of Snow White, the six-toed cat given to Hemingway by a ship’s captain. Go for the house tour, then leave yourself time to wander the grounds and spot the cats lounging around.


3. Shop for Locally Made KINO Sandals
A souvenir you’ll actually wear after vacation is always a win in my book. KINO Sandals has been making sandals in Key West since 1966, with leather uppers and rubber soles that are hand-cut and assembled at its traditional factory.
The shop is in Kino Plaza near Greene and Fitzpatrick Streets, so it’s easy to work into an Old Town wander.
Try on a few styles, and look for the sandal-making in progress while you’re there. Getting to see where your souvenir is made is what makes this stop worth seeking out.

4. Watch Wild Dolphins with Honest Eco
There are plenty of boat trips in Key West, but Honest Eco stands out for its wildlife-focused approach and electric catamaran, SQUID. Its Dolphin Watch and Guided Snorkel outing puts the emphasis on observing dolphins in their natural habitat and learning about the water you’re exploring.
This is the option I’d look at for a day that revolves around marine life. Wildlife sightings and snorkeling conditions vary, so go into it excited for the experience rather than expecting a guaranteed dolphin encounter or a particular reef stop.

5. Explore Key West’s Historic Cemetery
A cemetery might seem like an unexpected vacation stop, but this one offers a quieter way to get to know the island. The Key West Cemetery was established in 1847 after a hurricane disturbed the earlier burial ground. Walking through it gives you a glimpse of the people and communities that shaped Key West.
Pick up the free self-guided tour map at the entrance rather than wandering without context, or check the Historic Florida Keys Foundation’s guided-tour options.
You Might Love These Posts Too!
6. Eat Chocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie on a Stick
I’m absolutely making room for key lime pie in Key West, and the frozen, chocolate-dipped version from Kermit’s is such a fun way to have it. You get tart key lime filling, a graham cracker crust, and a chocolate shell, all served on a stick.
It’s a great dessert stop between sightseeing and shopping, especially on a hot afternoon. Grab one when you’re ready to eat it instead of carrying it around while you browse. Frozen pie and Florida heat don’t give you much time to debate your next stop!

7. Squeeze in a Drink at the Smallest Bar
At just 72 square feet, the Smallest Bar takes the tiny-bar concept seriously. You’ll find it at 124 Duval Street, near the Mallory Square end of the action. The fun is seeing just how little space a bar can take up and still become a memorable stop.
I’d treat this as a quick drink during a Duval Street bar crawl. There isn’t much room to settle in, which is part of the appeal. Have a drink, take a photo, and keep exploring.

8. Visit Robert the Doll at Fort East Martello
For the strangest stop on this list, head to Fort East Martello Museum to meet Robert the Doll. He’s been on display here since 1994 and comes with a long-running haunted reputation, plus apology letters from visitors who believe they offended him. Whether you buy into the stories or just enjoy local folklore, there’s a lot to talk about afterward.
The museum is on South Roosevelt Boulevard, outside the main Old Town sightseeing area, so plan transportation instead of treating it as a quick detour off Duval.
A daytime museum visit and the separately booked nighttime ghost experience are different outings; choose based on how spooky you want your evening to get.
You Might Love These Posts Too!
9. Take a Boat to Dinner at Latitudes
Dinner comes with a short boat ride when you book Latitudes on Sunset Key! You can only get here by ferry, and the ride takes less than 10 minutes, but it feels like a little escape from Key West. Between arriving by boat and dining right on the water, it’s easily one of the most unique things to do in Key West.
And the views? I was truly in awe. It’s such a beautiful setting for a meal, and they have some great seafood options to go with it. I’d keep this one in mind for a birthday, anniversary, or a special dinner during your trip!
Book well in advance, especially if you’re hoping for a sunset dinner. I booked over a month ahead, and nothing later than 4:45 PM was available! Also, your reservation time is your ferry departure time, so arrive at the dock beforehand.
Breakfast and lunch are worth considering if you can’t snag the dinner time you want.





10. See Shipwreck Treasure at the Mel Fisher Maritime Museum
The Mel Fisher Maritime Museum gives you a closer look at the shipwrecks and underwater discoveries tied to the Keys. Its collections include material from the 1622 Spanish fleet, including the famous Atocha, so you’re seeing artifacts connected to real wrecks rather than a pirate-themed attraction.
There’s more here than treasure: exhibits also cover the transatlantic slave trade and other maritime history. If you’re especially interested in what happens after an artifact is recovered, look into the museum’s separately ticketed conservation lab tour. It adds another layer to the story beyond what’s in the display cases.
11. Ride the Conch Tour Train
The little yellow Conch Tour Train has been part of Key West since 1958. It’s a familiar sight around town, and its long history here earns it a place on the list. This is an easy way to hear the island’s stories while taking a break from walking.
I’d put it near the beginning of a first visit so you can get your bearings before exploring on your own. This is a narrated sightseeing ride; be sure to check the current route and scheduled stops.

Where to Stay in Key West
Staying in Old Town makes it easy to walk to most of these spots, restaurants, and nightlife. Here are a few places to check out:
- Tranquility Guest House — Where we stayed! A cute pool area and about a 15-minute walk to Duval Street. We booked last minute, and it was one of the more affordable options for our dates.
- La Concha Key West — Right on Duval Street, with an outdoor pool and pool bar. A convenient pick for being close to restaurants and nightlife.
- Douglas House — A quieter inn just off Duval Street, with a tropical garden pool near the Hemingway House. Best for a relaxed getaway; bachelor and bachelorette groups aren’t accepted.
Ready to pick your home base? Compare availability and total prices for your dates.
Find Your Key West Stay
Which Unique Key West Experience Are You Trying First?
These unique things to do in Key West are what make the island so fun to explore! A ferry ride to an unforgettable dinner, six-toed cats wandering Hemingway’s gardens, and a slice of chocolate-dipped key lime pie all deserve a little room in your itinerary. Pick a few favorites, book the bigger experiences ahead of time, and leave yourself time to wander—you’ll want it!
Which of these unique Key West experiences would you try first?
Before you go, be sure to follow me on Insta @guidedbydestiny and check out some of my other Florida blog posts:
Best Florida Spring Break Destinations
Miami Bachelorette Party Guide

